Nov 1, 2023   ~ 15 min read

Black Friday and Cyber Monday Shopify Guide: Exceeding Customer Expectations for Stellar Service.

Praella Shopify Plus Agency - BFCM Guide

The biggest shopping days of the year are just around the corner. Black Friday and Cyber Monday mean big opportunities for your business but also big challenges when managing customer expectations and providing amazing service. You've spent months preparing your store, optimizing your product pages, and refining your marketing campaigns to drive more traffic. Now, the big question is - are you ready to handle the influx of orders and questions while maintaining your brand experience?

This comprehensive guide will walk you through strategies for building trust, clearly communicating with your customers about shipping and inventory, and keeping your support team motivated during the busy season. The key is planning ahead and staying focused on what really matters - your customers. Follow these tips to survive and thrive this Black Friday and Cyber Monday. The work you put in now will pay off in loyal, lifelong customers.

Set Accurate Delivery Expectations for Black Friday and Cyber Monday

Managing customer expectations around delivery and service is crucial during Black Friday and Cyber Monday. According to a recent survey, customers expect 15% faster shipping than last year. To keep your customers happy:

Set accurate delivery expectations

Be upfront about potential shipping delays on product pages and at checkout. Let customers know if two-day shipping isn’t guaranteed during this busy period. Consider offering free standard shipping to offset any disappointment.

Free shipping is a must. Customers anticipate and demand free delivery for Black Friday and Cyber Monday orders. Absorb the cost or build it into your prices to avoid abandoned carts.

Same-day delivery, while challenging, can delight customers. If you’re able to offer same-day delivery in certain areas, promote it in your store. Customers will appreciate the option even if they don’t use it.

Over-communicate at every step

Send order confirmations, shipping updates, and delivery notifications to keep customers in the loop. Let them know when their items have been packed, shipped, and are out for delivery. An informed customer is a happy customer.

Be active on social media. Respond to comments and questions, and post updates. Your followers will appreciate your responsiveness and transparency during this busy sales period.

Praella Shopify Plus Agency - Customer Service BFCM

Have more customer service reps on hand. Beef up support across live chat, email, and phone to quickly handle inquiries and issues. Faster response times lead to greater satisfaction and brand trust.

Following these best practices for managing expectations and delivering amazing service will build goodwill and turn first-time Black Friday and Cyber Monday customers into lifetime shoppers. With open communication and a great experience, you'll have customers returning for years.

Communicate Proactively About Orders and Shipping

During Black Friday and Cyber Monday, your customers expect fast, free shipping and quick delivery of their orders. It's up to you to manage those expectations and provide amazing service.

Communicate clearly about shipping times and stock levels

Let your customers know upfront about any potential shipping delays or low-stock warnings. Be transparent about the volume of orders you're experiencing and how that may impact delivery estimates. Offer alternative shipping options where possible, like expedited shipping.

  • Email customers as soon as they place an order with an estimate of when their item(s) will ship and be delivered. Provide updates if anything changes.

  • Post prominent notices about shipping cut-off dates, low-stock items, and any temporary shipping delays in your store.

  • Stay active on social media and address any customer concerns about shipping or inventory issues. Apologize for any inconvenience and provide a timeline for resolution.

Issue proactive updates about order and delivery status

Once items have shipped, send shipping notifications and delivery updates to keep customers informed about where their order is and when it's expected to arrive.

  • Email customers when orders are fulfilled and provide a tracking number. Ask them to check the shipping status for the most up-to-date delivery information.

  • Email again when the delivery carrier estimates the order will be delivered. Let customers know they can also check for real-time updates on the carrier's website using their tracking number.

  • Reach out if there are any delays or issues with a delivery. Explain the situation, apologize, and provide a new expected delivery date. Your proactive communication can help alleviate frustration and ensure a good experience.

Keeping communication lines open, setting expectations upfront, and providing proactive updates about orders and deliveries will build trust with your customers and help make Black Friday and Cyber Monday a success. Focus on transparency, empathy, and solutions to create memorable relationships and turn one-time shoppers into lifelong clients.

Have a Plan for Inventory and Stock Levels

Having a solid plan in place for managing your inventory and stock levels is essential during the busy holiday shopping season. As a Shopify merchant, you have access to powerful tools to help you stay on top of what’s selling and avoid disappointing customers with out-of-stock products.

Track Inventory in Real Time

With each sale, Shopify's built-in inventory tracking feature automatically updates quantities across all your locations and warehouses. You can also use an app like Stocky for more robust, detailed monitoring. Know at a glance what’s selling fast so you can reorder and avoid missing out on sales.

Shopify Inventory managment - Person keeping track of the inventory

Set a Buffer Stock

Don’t cut it too close with your inventory numbers. Set a buffer stock for each product, especially popular ones, to account for higher-than-expected demand and any shipping or supply chain delays. A buffer of 20-30% of typical stock is a good rule of thumb. That way, you’ll have extra on hand in case of surges in orders.

Communicate with Customers

Be transparent with your customers about any potential delays or shortages. Update product listings and your store’s shipping policy page to clearly state that although you strive to ship most items within X business days, certain products may have slightly longer delivery estimates during this busy time of year, especially for any low-stock or popular items. Let people know you appreciate their patience and understanding.

Have a Backup Plan

Despite your best efforts, there may be situations where some products sell out completely. Don’t panic – have a plan in place for how to handle out-of-stock products. You might offer customers alternative options, discount codes for future use, or the ability to backorder the item. You should also have suppliers or distributors on standby that may be able to rush additional inventory if needed.

By monitoring stock levels closely, maintaining buffer inventory, communicating proactively with customers, and having contingency plans ready, you’ll be well-equipped to provide great service even during the busiest, most high-demand periods. Your customers will appreciate your transparency and ability to deliver on your promises.

Provide Amazing Customer Service During Peak Times

During the busy holiday shopping season, providing amazing customer service is key to building customer trust and loyalty. As a Shopify merchant, focus on:

Clear Communication

Double-check that your shipping and return policies, processing times, and inventory levels are clearly stated in your store. Send email campaigns ahead of big sales events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday to set proper customer expectations about potential delays. Be transparent that your team may handle a high volume of orders and messages, and appreciate customers’ patience.

Personalized Interactions

Use your CRM or helpdesk software to review each customer’s purchase history and past interactions before responding. Address them by name and reference their loyalty or concerns. For example, say, “Thank you for shopping with us again this season, [Name]. We appreciate your continued business and support.” Personalization, even in small ways, can make a big difference.

Praella Shopify Plus Agency - BFCM Customer Support

Streamlined Processes

Look for ways to automate and simplify operations during busy periods. Set up canned email responses to frequently asked questions. Create saved replies in your helpdesk for common issues. Enable a chatbot on your store to handle basic questions. The more you can optimize repetitive tasks, the more time your team will have to focus on complex customer issues.

Going Above and Beyond

Consider offering exclusive perks or discounts for your most loyal or high-value customers. Send a small gift, or handwritten thank you card. Check-in on them personally to ensure their needs are met. Making a memorable impression through extraordinary service will turn customers into lifelong brand advocates.

Providing an amazing experience during the holidays requires planning and dedication. But by focusing on clear communication, personalization, streamlining operations, and going above and beyond for your best customers, you’ll build trust, foster relationships, and keep shoppers coming back - not just this season but for years to come.

Learn From This Holiday Season to Improve for Next Year

The holiday season is exciting yet stressful for any Shopify store owner. While managing increased traffic and sales is thrilling, it also brings challenges like ensuring your support team can handle the influx of customer inquiries. The key is learning from this year’s successes and struggles to better prepare for next season.

Focus on optimizing personalized service. Build loyalty by providing tailored support for your customers. Send post-purchase follow-up emails thanking them for their business and asking for feedback on their experience. Survey customers about what they liked and areas for improvement. Use that information to enhance your customer journey for 2022.

Refine your shipping and returns policy. Clearly communicate delivery timeframes and return eligibility on your store, in emails, and at checkout. Set proper expectations upfront to avoid confusion and frustration. Consider offering express shipping as an option for those wanting gifts in time for the holidays. Allow for extended return periods to accommodate gift returns.

Review your inventory and stock levels. It’s frustrating for customers to purchase items only to receive a cancelation notice because the product is out of stock. Audit your inventory to determine popular products and appropriate stock levels to have on hand for increased demand. You may need to increase stock for the peak season temporarily.

Evaluate your staffing and support. Determine if you had adequate coverage to handle the influx of questions, issues, and concerns. You may need to bring on seasonal help for the next holiday season to prevent long wait times and dropped inquiries. Provide additional training to ensure staff can resolve common questions and deliver amazing service.

The end of the year is an opportunity to pause and evaluate what went well and what could be improved for your Shopify store. Using customer feedback and performance metrics, build a plan of action to optimize your customer experience, shipping, inventory, staffing, and more for the next holiday season. Continuous improvement and learning from each year will help you master the busy period and keep your customers coming back.


You've got this. Now that you know what to expect and how to prepare, you can provide amazing customer service during the busy shopping season. Be transparent in your communication, set proper expectations about shipping and inventory, and your customers will love you for it. Stay calm and focus on what really matters - building great relationships with your loyal customers. Before you know it, the rush will be over, and you'll be gearing up for next year, armed with the knowledge and experience to make it even better. The holidays will be here and gone in the blink of an eye, so take a deep breath and enjoy this special time of year. You've built an amazing business; now go out there and spread the joy to all your customers. They'll surely return the favor.

Praella Shopify Plus Agency - FAQ


Q: What is Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: Black Friday and Cyber Monday are annual shopping days that offer massive discounts and deals on various products and services. Black Friday falls on the Friday after Thanksgiving, while Cyber Monday occurs on the Monday following Black Friday. These days have become synonymous with holiday shopping and are a great opportunity for retailers to boost their sales.

Q: How can Shopify help me with Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: Shopify is an ecommerce platform providing tools and resources to help businesses build and manage online stores. With Shopify, you can prepare your store for Black Friday and Cyber Monday by optimizing your website, creating promotional campaigns, and managing customer expectations.

Q: How can I prepare my Shopify store for Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: To prepare your Shopify store for Black Friday and Cyber Monday, you can optimize your website for speed and performance. Make sure your store can handle increased traffic and offer a seamless shopping experience. Additionally, you can create eye-catching landing pages, set up promotions and discounts, and implement abandoned cart recovery emails to maximize conversions.

Q: Are there any apps available on Shopify to help with Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: Yes, Shopify offers many apps that can help you with Black Friday and Cyber Monday preparations. Some popular apps include email marketing tools, SMS marketing solutions, loyalty programs, and widgets to display promotions and discounts on your website. These apps can assist you in driving traffic, increasing conversions, and retaining customers during the holiday season.

Q: How can I manage customer expectations during Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: Managing customer expectations is crucial during Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Clearly communicate your shipping and delivery policies, return and exchange procedures, and estimated delivery times. Provide excellent customer support and be responsive to inquiries and concerns. Setting realistic expectations and delivering on your promises will help ensure a positive shopping experience for your customers.

Q: How can I deliver amazing service to my customers during Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: To deliver amazing service to your customers during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, focus on providing a seamless and personalized shopping experience. Make sure your website is user-friendly and optimized for mobile devices. Offer exceptional customer support through various channels like live chat, email, and phone. Send post-purchase emails to thank customers for their purchase and provide any necessary follow-up information.

Q: How can I optimize my Shopify store for better conversions during Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: To optimize your Shopify store for better conversions during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, you can implement strategies such as improving your website design and layout, offering limited-time promotions and discounts, integrating customer reviews and testimonials, streamlining the checkout process, and leveraging upselling and cross-selling techniques. Analyze your conversion rate and make data-driven adjustments to improve your overall performance.

Q: How can I attract new customers to my Shopify store during Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: There are several marketing strategies you can use to attract new customers to your Shopify store during Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Some effective methods include running targeted advertising campaigns, collaborating with influencers and affiliates, leveraging social media marketing, offering exclusive discounts for new customers, and creating engaging content to generate buzz and increase brand awareness.

Q: What is the significance of Black Friday and Cyber Monday for my ecommerce business?

A: Black Friday and Cyber Monday can be significantly beneficial for your ecommerce business. These shopping days attract a large number of consumers actively seeking deals and discounts, offering you the opportunity to boost your sales and revenue. You can increase brand exposure, acquire new customers, and strengthen customer loyalty by implementing effective marketing and promotional strategies.

Q: How can I effectively promote my Shopify store for Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

A: To effectively promote your Shopify store for Black Friday and Cyber Monday, you can utilize various marketing channels and tactics. Some popular options include email marketing, social media advertising, influencer partnerships, content marketing, SMS marketing, and optimizing your website for search engines. A well-rounded promotional campaign will help you reach a wider audience and drive more traffic to your store.

Effective Inventory Management Strategies: Best Practices for Inventory, Counts, and Techniques
Ecommerce Strategies to Prepare Your Shopify Store for the Biggest Shopping Season